5
QuizMultiple Choice

Evaluating Scientific Explanations

Question 5 • FL-2001340-Environmental Science A-CR

Terrence claims that a new species of bacteria should be placed on the list of bacteria that cause infectious diseases. He ran his experiment several times in one day and got the same results. Ben and Frieda also ran his experiment multiple times themselves. They never got the same results that Terrence did.

Answer
A
It is invalid because it could not stand up to experimentation.
B
It is valid because only one person needs to validate it.
C
It is valid because he did the experiment multiple times.
D
It is invalid because bacteria are always changing.

Explanation

A scientific claim should be reproducible: other people should be able to repeat the experiment and get similar results. Terrence repeated it himself, but Ben and Frieda could not reproduce his results, so the claim has not stood up to independent experimentation. Therefore, choice A is correct; repeating the experiment only once with the same person, as in choice C, is not enough to establish the claim.

AI-written and checked against the verified answer.

Previous
Next