Question 1 • CA-Common Core English Language Arts 11 B
“Formed by years of erosion” is a phrase that adds extra information about the canyon; it does not identify which canyon is meant. The commas show that this added detail is nonessential, so it is a nonrestrictive phrase. A restrictive phrase would be needed to distinguish the canyon from others, and a clause would contain a subject and verb.
AI-written and checked against the verified answer.