Evaluating an Argument

Question 6 • GA-Literature and Composition II (Fakunle)

Which statement would be an effective conclusion for the evaluation of an article on the potential threat of technology?

Answer

Finally, Wilson’s article argues that technology is detrimental to learning because fewer students are reading for pleasure.

I agree with Wilson’s argument. When I stopped watching videos on my phone, my grades went up, so technology must make it more difficult to learn.

Wilson’s article states that computers, tablets, and smartphones should not be allowed in the classroom because these devices distract students.

Therefore, Wilson's argument that technology makes it more difficult for students to concentrate is thoroughly researched and provides ample supporting evidence.

Explanation

An effective conclusion to an evaluation gives an overall judgment about how well the article supports its argument. Choice D concludes that Wilson’s argument is thoroughly researched and supported by ample evidence, so it evaluates the article’s effectiveness. Choice A and C mainly summarize what Wilson says, while B relies on a personal anecdote to make a broad claim.

AI-written and checked against the verified answer.

More from this Course

Assignment

Assignment

Instruction