Part 4: Writing an Argumentative Paragraph about an Informational Text — Quiz
Question 2 • English 4
Read the claim and counterclaim. Claim : The marine chronometer was the most historically important artifact because it made it possible for international trade to flourish. Counterclaim : At the time the marine chronometer was invented, international trade was already taking place. Which statement is the strongest rebuttal to the counterclaim?
Answer
A
However, the marine chronometer finally made accurate maps possible, creating safe, rapid, and efficient shipping routes.
B
Even so, it was the marine chronometer that allowed Charles Darwin to make his famous voyage and publish his findings about evolution.
C
However, Thomas Earnshaw’s invention of an affordable chronometer meant that virtually any ship could carry one aboard.
D
Even so, international trade would have continued to expand and prosper by finding alternate ways to make trade by sea more effective.
Explanation
The counterclaim points out that trade existed before the marine chronometer, but that does not show the chronometer failed to make trade safer or more efficient. Choice A explains how it helped make accurate maps and reliable shipping routes possible, showing how it could transform and expand trade that was already happening. Choice B concerns Darwin’s voyage, not international trade.
AI-written and checked against the verified answer.