8
QuizMultiple Choice

Rhetoric and Fallacy

Question 8 • (OC27) Intensive Reading 3-1000416-S1-VRobinson-VOL7006P=TG97%

Maya is arguing that schools should allow students to bring cell phones to school. She says, "All students agree that cell phones in school are a good idea.”

Answer
A
Ninety-six percent of students who were surveyed support allowing cell phones in school.
B
The majority of students support allowing cell phones, so it must be the best choice.
C
Banning cell phones from school will put students in dangerous situations if they cannot reach their parents.
D
Anyone who does not support cell phones in school believes that students should not be allowed to express themselves.

Explanation

Choice A provides survey evidence that supports Maya’s claim: 96 percent of the students surveyed favor allowing phones at school. It does not prove that every student agrees, so the claim “all students” is an exaggeration, but A is the strongest relevant support. The other choices rely on an unsupported conclusion, a possible safety concern, or an unfair attack on people who disagree.

AI-written and checked against the verified answer.

Previous
Next