8
QuizMultiple Choice

Dating Methods: Relative & Absolute — Quiz

Question 8 • Earth and Space Science

A scientist is observing a rock found near a crater where an asteroid once collided with Earth. The scientist wants to determine if the rock they are observing is from Earth or from the asteroid. The oldest rock on Earth is 4.5 billion years old. The rock from the asteroid is much older than rock on Earth. The scientist uses U-235 U-Pb dating on the rock and finds that 55% of the uranium-235 in the rock has changed to lead-207. Which statement is best supported by the scientist's evidence?

Answer
A
The rock is a little older than 704 million years old, so it is likely from Earth.
B
The rock is a little younger than 704 million years old, so it is likely from Earth.
C
The rock is a little older than 704 million years old, so it is likely from the asteroid.
D
The rock is a little younger than 704 million years old, so it is likely from the asteroid.

Explanation

If 55% of the uranium-235 has changed into lead-207, then 45% of the original uranium-235 remains. Since less than half remains, the rock is older than one half-life of U-235, about 704 million years. Its age is about 811 million years, which is far younger than the 4.5-billion-year age of Earth's oldest rocks, so the evidence supports that it came from Earth; choice A is best.

AI-written and checked against the verified answer.

Previous
Next