9
SWMultiple Choice

Part 4: Writing an Argumentative Paragraph about an Informational Text

Question 9 • [HSPE2] PE Sem 4 (26-27)

Which statement is the strongest counterclaim to the claim?Claim: The marine chronometer is the most historically significant object because it allowed for the rise of global trade.

Answer
A
The use of the chronometer did not become routine on Royal Navy ships until 1800.
B
As shown in the discussion of the Benin plaques, Europeans traveled to faraway places before the chronometer was invented.
C
The Industrial Revolution was a greater factor than the chronometer in the development of an efficient railway system.
D
Countries had been trading globally for centuries before the chronometer, and they would have continued to do so without it.

Explanation

The claim says the chronometer was historically significant because it allowed global trade to rise. Choice D directly challenges that cause-and-effect idea: global trade had already existed for centuries, and it would have continued without the chronometer. Choice B only shows that Europeans traveled far away before the chronometer, not that global trade did not depend on it.

AI-written and checked against the verified answer.

Previous
Next